Comprehensive Car Insurance Or Third Party: Which Is Better?

A red toy car being held in hand by a person, with car insurance form on the table.

22 Nov Comprehensive Car Insurance Or Third Party: Which Is Better?

When it comes to getting NZ car insurance, car owners face an important decision: Comprehensive car insurance or third-party car insurance? Each type of car insurance offers its own benefits and drawbacks, serving different needs and budgets. To help you make an informed decision about which one is right for you, get the pros and cons of both comprehensive and third-party car insurance here.

Comprehensive Car Insurance

Comprehensive car insurance is often considered the gold standard when it comes to insurance coverage, as it provides the highest level of protection for your car and for others on the road. Here are the key advantages and disadvantages of comprehensive car insurance:


  • Extensive coverage: Comprehensive car insurance covers the widest range of scenarios, including accidental damage to your car and other cars, and any property. This type of insurance also covers against theft, fire, vandalism, and natural disasters, which means you’re protected in a variety of situations beyond just accidents.
  • Protection for your car: In the event of an accident, comprehensive car insurance covers the cost of repairing or replacing your car, regardless of who is at fault.
  • Peace of mind: Knowing that you have comprehensive car insurance coverage can offer peace of mind, especially if you have a newer or more valuable car. Having to cover the significant cost of any damage incurred out of your own pocket, could easily set you back thousands of dollars.
  • Optional add-ons: Some insurance providers offer the option to add extras to your comprehensive car insurance policy, such as roadside assistance, rental car coverage, key replacement, and more, tailoring your policy to your specific needs.


  • Higher premiums: Comprehensive car insurance tends to have higher premiums compared to third party car insurance because of its extensive coverage. If you have an older car with a lower value, the cost of comprehensive car insurance may outweigh the potential benefits.

Third-Party Car Insurance

Third-party car insurance provides a more basic form of car insurance coverage, protecting you against any claims made by other parties when you’re involved in an accident. However, as it’s usually the cheapest NZ insurance option available, third-party car insurance doesn’t cover any damage to your own car. Here are some other advantages and disadvantages:


  • Affordability: Third-party car insurance tends to have lower premiums, making it a more budget-friendly option for many drivers. Third-party best suits drivers of low value cars who are willing and able to pay for the cost of repairs or replacement.


  • Limited coverage: Third party car insurance doesn’t cover any damage to your own car, and only covers damage or injury caused to other parties involved in an accident.
  • Out-of-pocket expenses: Because of its limited coverage, if you’re at fault in an accident, you’ll have to pay for the repair or replacement of your own vehicle.
  • No protection from theft or natural disasters: Third party car insurance doesn’t provide any coverage for theft, fire, or other non-collision related incidents.

Find the right car insurance for your needs

Deciding between comprehensive and third-party car insurance ultimately comes down to your individual circumstances and preferences. If you own a newer, higher-value car and want maximum protection, then comprehensive car insurance is the better choice. However, if you’re on a budget and have an older vehicle, third party insurance may be sufficient.

When deciding on the right car insurance for your needs, it helps to get sound advice from an expert, such as those at Max Insurances. Talk to an Insurance Adviser today and get help navigating the options and finding a car insurance policy that offers the best balance of protection and affordability. No matter where you are located, Max Insurances can help you arrange insurance NZ wide.

Request a Call Get a Quote

Find this article helpful? Don’t forget to like it or share it on Facebook.